"No it is not"? You know more law than the judge????  

You know more law than the judge???? If so, then I expect the ruling to be promptly appealed (you could do it, right, with your knowledge of NY law.) and set aside.

No doubt Giuliani will sue.

"just think they have been trying get Trump for over four years and still NO laws found broken.  They are just a court wasting money, trying to get Trump, no crimes found. Just a waste of time."

Not so. Presidential immunity was in effect preventing prosecution. That's why grand juries are sitting now to consider prosecutions.